Friday, November 22, 2013

The Morning Call--Bad news is still good news

The Morning Call

11/22/13

The Market
           
    Technical

            The indices (DJIA 16009, S&P 1795) resumed their move up, with the Dow breaching 16000 but the S&P falling short of 1800.  Both remained within uptrends across all time frames: short term (15339-20339, 1724-1878), intermediate term (15339-20339, 1635-2217) and long term (5015-17000, 728-1850).

            Volume fell; breadth improved.  The VIX was down 6%, again nearing the lower boundary of its short term trading range (a penetration would be a plus for stocks).  It ended within its intermediate term downtrend.  In addition, it looks like the second ‘outside’ down day experienced earlier in the week will suffer the same fate as the first, i.e. worthlessness.

            The long Treasury rose slightly, finishing with its short term trading range and intermediate term downtrend.

            GLD (119.94) was off, closing within its short term downtrend and on the lower boundary of its intermediate term downtrend.  It is once again nearing the lower boundary of its long term trading range (114.43) ---a break of which would be very negative for GLD.

Bottom line:  the assault on 16000/1800 is on again with the Dow managing to close above 16000 and the S&P falling short.  The technical question is, will this assault be successful?  Certainly, there is no reason to doubt momentum.  In addition, the chorus of bears is growing predicting that stocks will experience a blow off top before rolling over.  I wonder about their motivation; but whatever, it is, the consensus seems to be for more upside. 

I continue to believe that the upper boundaries of the Averages long term uptrends are the most logical upside objectives, especially with stocks so overvalued fundamentally.  That is not much reward to chase if the downside risk is Fair Value (S&P 1430).

So my recommendation continues to be to take advantage of the current high prices and any additional move to the upside to sell any stock that has been a disappointment and to trim the holding of any stock that has doubled or more in price.

If one of our stocks trades into its Sell Half Range, our Portfolios will act accordingly.

            Market at record spread to analysts’ expectations (short):
           
            Chart of the day (short):

            An historical review of Market performance in December (short):

            Update on sentiment (short):
           
    Fundamental
    
     Headlines

            Yesterday’s US economic news was mostly positive: weekly jobless claims fell more than anticipated, October PPI was tame and the November Markit PMI reading was above consensus. 

The only negative number was the November Philly Fed manufacturing index.  But of course, investors in this ‘bad news is good news’ environment chose to positively interpret that along with some lousy industrial production stats from the EU and a poor Chinese flash PMI and resume the attack on 16000/1800.

In political news, Yellen’s nomination for Fed chief received the approval of the senate banking committee and will be sent to the full senate for a vote.

The other item worth mentioning is that senate democrats voted to end the rule requiring a 60 vote majority for cloture on nominations of judicial and executive nominations.  This ends a rule that, as a conservative, I valued because it was a curb on legislative activism (he who governs least, governs best).  While it is true that it only applies to nominations, it is a short step to include all votes in the senate.  So for those who think that an improvement in fiscal policy is one of the keys to getting our economic house in order, this is bad news.  To be clear, I believe that this change in the legislative process will be just a detrimental to political/social/economic policy if the conservatives are in the majority.  It is not good for our democracy whoever is in the majority.

Bottom line: none of the above stats alter the assumptions in either of our Models.  So I remain stuck in an environment in which stocks are considerably overvalued.  I can point to multiple scenarios in which stocks return to Fair Value, not the least of which is a painful transition from easy to tight money brought by either increasingly cynical investors, a tightening Chinese central bank or a bungling by the Fed. 

That said, I remain on the wrong side of this trade.  But as much as I challenge my own assumptions, I can’t come up with a logical scenario that values the S&P at 1800.  As a corollary, our Valuation Model has many stocks valued at or above their Sell Half Range and that has pushed our Portfolios cash position to 40-45%.  The good news is that our Portfolios are still 55-60% invested; the bad news is that they are only 55-60% invested. 

So as an investor not a trader, my long term strategy calls for me to sit on my hands until valuations return to normalcy.

            More on QE and the damage that it has done (long but a must read):

            Sternlicht on the QE melt up (4 minute video):

            QE for as far as the eyes can see (medium):

            The latest from Doug Kass (medium):

            Five themes for the next five years (medium):

            The yield curve and ‘bubbles’ (medium):

       Investing for Survival

            Five numbers you need to know before paying 2014 taxes (medium):




Steve Cook received his education in investments from Harvard, where he earned an MBA, New York University, where he did post graduate work in economics and financial analysis and the CFA Institute, where he earned the Chartered Financial Analysts designation in 1973. His 40 years of investment experience includes institutional portfolio management at Scudder, Stevens and Clark and Bear Stearns. Steve's goal at Investing For Survival is to help other investors build wealth and benefit from the investing lessons he learned the hard way.

No comments:

Post a Comment