Wednesday, May 29, 2013

The Morning Call--Our Economic Model is on track, our Valuation Model is a different story

The Morning Call

5/29/13

The Market
           
    Technical

              The indices (DJIA 15409, S&P 1660) had another good day.  Of course, it was Tuesday, so stocks had to go up (now 20 in a row).  The Averages closed within all major uptrends: short term (14551-15265, 1596-1673 [ the Dow was above its upper boundary]), intermediate term (14002-19002, 1486-2074) and long term (4783-17500, 688-1750).

            Volume rose; breadth improved.  The VIX was up again on a strong up price day.  In addition, bond prices are falling across the yield curve and high dividend paying stocks are getting whacked.  I don’t regard this development as healthy unless the economy is or is about to begin growing at a much faster rate---which I don’t think that it is.

            And then there is the Japanese bond market (short):

            ***over night the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) lowered its forecast for global economic growth in 2013.

            GLD fell.  It finished below the lower boundary of its intermediate term downtrend but above both its recent double bottom and the lower boundary of its long term uptrend.  Despite the clamor among technicians and gold bears that prices are going lower, I think GLD has performed admirably of late.  Nonetheless, I would like to see a bounce above at least one of its short term downtrends before venturing back into GLD.

Bottom line: stocks continued to their relentless advance.  As I noted yesterday, until ‘buying the dips’ ceases to be a winning strategy, there is nothing for me to do but sit on the sidelines and wait.  It is not like I am in agony; our Portfolios are still 60% invested.  So we are making money.  Nevertheless, our Sell Discipline pushed our Portfolios to a higher cash position sooner than, in retrospect, I would have liked.  That said, I review the assumptions and conclusions of our Valuation Model regularly; and so far I have no reason to doubt that it won’t ultimately prove correct on valuations---it was just premature in timing.

Meanwhile, (m)y strategy continues to be to take advantage of what I consider unwarranted optimism by lightening up on positions when the stock price trades into its Sell Half Range.  I believe that we will have a chance to buy these shares back at much lower price.’

            Margin debt hits all time high (short):

            Update on the Shanghai Composite (short):

    Fundamental

     Headlines

            A slew of stats were out yesterday, most of them above expectations: the March Case Shiller home price index rose as did May consumer confidence.  In addition, the May Richmond Fed’s manufacturing index while down was better than anticipated.  On the other hand, the May Dallas Fed’s manufacturing index came in worse than estimated. 

            However, what made investors feel all warm and fuzzy was....drum roll....more comments from the central bankers (this time the ECB and the BOJ) about the need for lower rates and easier money.  The magic elixir of free money will continue to drive stock prices up until investors finally figure out just how painful the exit is going to be.  Until then..........

Bottom line: the above datapoints fit perfectly with our ‘sluggishly growing economy’ scenario.  So this keeps our Economic Model on track and me mildly encouraged.  That said, our economic scenario produces considerably lower equity prices in our Valuation Model than currently exists in the Market.  Further, if interest rates continue to advance, that will act as a negative on discount rates (P/E’s). 

It is clearly disconcerting to me that factors that would lift equity valuations (economic growth, both here and abroad, earnings growth) are struggling not accelerating and those factors that would lower valuations (monstrous infusions of money, increasing interest rates) are rising and perhaps accelerating.  None of this squares with current Market performance; and I have no erudite explanation of why it is so.
    
            More on valuation (medium):

            The economics of stock buybacks (medium and a must read):
            http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-05-28/presenting-full-impact-stock-buybacks-sp-500-earnings

            Another great analysis on valuations from Lance Roberts (medium and also a  must read):





Steve Cook received his education in investments from Harvard, where he earned an MBA, New York University, where he did post graduate work in economics and financial analysis and the CFA Institute, where he earned the Chartered Financial Analysts designation in 1973. His 40 years of investment experience includes institutional portfolio management at Scudder, Stevens and Clark and Bear Stearns. Steve's goal at

No comments:

Post a Comment